Can an HOA change rules without a vote? When faced with displeasing rule changes, homeowners often ask whether boards can change the rules unilaterally. Since homeowners are also members of the community, they wish to have a say in everything that goes on. But votes are not always necessary when it comes to rule changes, ultimately depending on the situation.
Can HOA Change Rules Without a Vote?
Homeowners associations are responsible for enforcing rules and regulations. These rules exist to maintain order and aesthetic appeal, thereby preserving property values. But not everyone agrees with the rules, and changes, particularly drastic ones, can upset owners. This begs the question, “Can an HOA change rules without a vote?”
The answer isn’t so black-and-white. It really depends on state laws and the association’s governing documents. Some states require a membership vote for certain amendments, while others leave it up to the board.
For example, in North Carolina, Section 47F-3-103 states that the board can’t unilaterally amend the declaration, but it can amend the bylaws as per Section 47F-3-102. In Virginia, Section 55.1-1829 requires a two-thirds vote to amend the declaration, except as provided otherwise.
More often than not, state laws defer to the association’s own bylaws and CC&Rs for the requirements and method of amendments.
Breaking Down the Type of Rule Changes
“Rules” is a general term that can encompass an association’s CC&Rs, bylaws, and rules and regulations. While these documents share some similarities, they serve different purposes. Amendments can also vary in voting requirements. Let’s break them down below.
Can HOA Change CC&Rs Without a Vote?
In general, an HOA or condominium can’t amend its declaration or CC&Rs without a membership vote. After proposing an amendment, the board must set a meeting wherein homeowners can vote to either pass or reject the change.
While this is the general rule, it will ultimately depend on where the association is located and what its governing documents say. State laws can vary greatly, and some are even silent on the issue. When in doubt, board members should consult legal counsel.
Can HOA Change Bylaws Without a Vote?
As with CC&Rs, the bylaws follow the same general rule. Some states legally require a membership vote to approve amendments to the bylaws, but many defer to the association’s bylaws themselves. For instance, in North Carolina, Section 47F-3-106 dictates that the bylaws must provide for the method of amendment.
Can HOA Change Rules Without a Vote?
Operating rules are a different story. These rules serve to expound on or clarify the covenants and restrictions, thereby reducing the amendment requirements. Generally, the board can change the rules without a membership vote, but it must be voted on by the board and passed through a resolution.
Can an HOA Change Rules After Purchase?
Homeowners typically receive a copy of the governing documents as part of their disclosure packet. While this is done to set buyer expectations, it is a mistake to assume that the contents of the documents will stay the same forever. On the contrary, it is normal for an association to amend its rules over time, especially as needs and laws change.
An HOA or condo association can generally change the rules even after purchase. As long as the rules were properly enacted or amended, then they are valid. That said, there are exceptions, particularly when a grandfather clause applies.
A grandfather clause is a provision that permits existing owners or situations to continue to operate under old rules despite a rule change. The policy instead applies to future owners or cases. This clause does not apply to all rules; it applies only to those that explicitly say so.
For instance, in Washington, D.C., newly enacted rental restrictions don’t apply to owners who had already been leasing their units. The change will apply only to owners who move back into their units or to new owners (Section 42–1903.08).
Can HOA Change Rules Without Notice?
Generally, associations can’t change their rules without proper notice. Homeowners have a right to know what’s going on in their community, including policy changes. If owners aren’t made aware of the amendment, then boards can’t reasonably hold them accountable for violations.
Notice requirements vary depending on state laws and the association’s governing documents. That said, notice is usually required regardless of whether the change affects the CC&Rs, bylaws, or operating rules.
Are HOA Rules Legally Binding?
Yes, HOA rules are legally binding, provided:
- The rules were properly enacted,
- The association has the authority to enforce those rules (as per state laws and the governing documents), and
- The rules do not conflict with the law.
Homeowners agree to abide by HOA rules upon joining the community. It is a contractual obligation on their part. If they wish to avoid penalties, including fines and suspension of privileges, they must follow the rules.
Of course, that doesn’t mean owners can’t challenge the rules or dispute violations. They can certainly do so if they believe the rules are unreasonable, obsolete, or improper. Most state laws also mandate an opportunity to be heard before an HOA imposes a penalty for rule violations.
Can Homeowners Change HOA Rules?
Homeowners can’t change the rules in the technical sense, but they are not totally powerless. They can get involved in the community to affect real change. For one thing, homeowners should attend meetings to understand community issues. Boards discuss and vote on rule changes at these meetings, and simply showing up can make a difference.
Additionally, homeowners should not be afraid of offering feedback or input. If they disagree with a proposed policy, they should speak up and make it known. Board meetings usually allot time for comments. Other communities have complaint forms or suggestion boxes.
For decision-making power, homeowners should consider joining the board. This will allow them to serve the community more actively.
Practice Caution
Can the HOA change rules without a vote? The answer is, it depends. Changes to the CC&Rs and bylaws typically require a vote by homeowners, but simple rule changes require only a board resolution. Boards must follow proper procedure, or amendments may be voided.
Clark Simson Miller offers HOA management services to community associations. Call us today at 865.315.7505 or reach out to us online to request a proposal!
RELATED ARTICLES:
- Can Homeowners Vote For A HOA Contractor?
- Can The HOA Vote On Special Assessments?
-
- HOA Duty To Protect: A Legal Obligation Or A Courtesy?