vote for hoa contractor

Can you allow homeowners to vote for an HOA contractor? This is a question many HOA boards face, especially during large projects that require significant funds. While the HOA board is typically responsible for selecting contractors, there are scenarios where homeowner input becomes necessary. Regardless, board members should prioritize transparency in all business decisions.

 

Can Homeowners Vote for HOA Contractor?

Homeowners often wonder if they can vote for the contractors hired by their HOA. Transparency and collaboration are crucial for maintaining trust between boards and residents. While choosing a contractor is typically the board’s responsibility, there are exceptional circumstances in which homeowner involvement comes in. It is important to understand all variables at play.

 

The Role of the HOA Board in Picking Contractors

Your HOA board is primarily responsible for selecting contractors for community projects. Boards are entrusted with the duty to act in the community’s best interests. The governing documents of an HOA outline this responsibility.

In most cases, boards have the authority to research, evaluate, and hire contractors without direct homeowner votes. They must ensure projects are completed efficiently, within budget, and with high standards. This process also involves comparing bids, verifying licenses, and negotiating contracts.

State laws and regulations can sometimes impact how boards must choose contractors. For example, in Colorado, boards use a budget ratification process for special assessments (Section 38-33.3-303). Unless an HOA’s governing documents say otherwise, no approval from homeowners is necessary to pass a budget. However, owners can veto the budget through a majority vote.

 

When Can Homeowners Vote for HOA Contractors?

Homeowners typically don’t vote directly on contractors, but there are situations where their input may be necessary.

 

1. Special Assessments

For major projects that would require a special assessment, homeowners may vote on whether to approve the assessment. While this vote focuses on funding, boards usually present contractor estimates to explain the amount. When board members allow homeowners to vote for HOA contractors indirectly, they can help gather support for the project.

For instance, if a community pool requires repairs, the board may share estimates from three contractors. Homeowners then decide whether to approve the special assessment based on these costs.

Remember that not all HOAs need a vote from owners to pass a special assessment. It will ultimately depend on state laws and the HOA’s own governing documents.

 

2. Smaller or Self-Managed HOAs

In smaller or self-managed communities, boards may allow homeowners to vote directly on contractor options. This informal approach is a good idea for small communities where residents share the decision-making power.

 

3. Advisory Votes for Big Projects

Some HOA boards seek homeowner input through non-binding votes or surveys. This means homeowners can provide feedback and “vote” whether or not to push through with a project. However, these “votes” are simply a count of support or opposition — not actual votes that dictate the project’s outcome. Surveys and advisory votes allow residents to express preferences without delaying the process.

 

Benefits of Homeowner Involvement

Although boards handle most contractor decisions, there are a few benefits to involving homeowners in the process. For one thing, it promotes transparency within the community and strengthens trust. When board members share information with owners, owners are likelier to back the board on decisions.

Another benefit is that it offers diverse perspectives. Homeowners may offer valuable insights or recommendations that the board did not previously consider. Boards can sometimes operate with blinders that fail to take in all viewpoints. Allowing homeowners to provide input helps mitigate this.

 

Challenges of Allowing Voting for HOA Contractors

While involving homeowners in contractor decisions can promote transparency, it also comes with challenges.

 

1. Lack of Expertise

Most homeowners lack the knowledge needed to evaluate contractor bids effectively. Boards consider factors like licensing, insurance, contingencies, and permits. Without this expertise, homeowners may go with a poor option. Typically, homeowners simply want the cheapest contractor because it would mean a lower fee or assessment for them. Ultimately, this compromises quality.

 

2. Delays in Decision-Making

Voting processes can slow down projects, especially urgent ones that require immediate action. Contractors often need deposits or signed contracts to secure their services. With delays, HOAs may face higher costs or miss out on good opportunities.

 

3. Legal and Financial Risks

Boards must provide homeowners with detailed information about contractor bids and project specifics. This information can lead to disputes or render decisions unenforceable if this information is incomplete. Transparency is critical, particularly for special assessments.

 

HOA contractors4. Conflicts of Interest

Allowing homeowners to vote for HOA contractors can lead to favoritism. For instance, a resident might push for a contractor they personally know, even if that contractor is not the best choice.

 

Best Practices for Transparency

To balance homeowner input with effective decision-making, boards should adopt transparent practices.

 

1. Share Detailed Estimates

Boards should present homeowners with comprehensive contractor bids. These bids should include costs, timelines, permits, and contingencies. For example, many contractors add a 20% contingency fee for unexpected issues. Sharing these details helps homeowners understand the scope of the project.

 

2. Clarify Overages

Boards should explain how excess funds will be handled if there is leftover money from the project. The HOA board can deposit the excess money into the association’s reserves. Alternatively, the board may refund the overages to homeowners.

 

voting for hoa contractors3. Conduct Surveys

If direct voting isn’t practical, surveys can help gather homeowner feedback. For example, a survey might ask homeowners to rank contractor options based on certain criteria or parameters. This input can guide the board’s decision and let owners feel involved in the selection process.

 

Why Boards Should Lead in Most Cases

Despite the benefits of homeowner input, contractor selection often requires expertise that boards are better equipped to provide. Boards have the tools to analyze bids, compare contractor qualifications, and ensure compliance with legal requirements. After all, homeowners elect the board members to represent them, so they should trust in their decisions.

For time-sensitive projects, letting the board lead also helps ensure an efficient decision-making process. However, boards can maintain transparency by sharing information, gathering feedback, and explaining their choices to homeowners. This approach fosters trust while prioritizing the community’s best interests.

 

Vote for HOA Contractor or Not

Should you allow homeowners to vote for HOA contractors? In most cases, the board should handle contractor selection. However, there are times when homeowner input can be beneficial. Whatever the case, board members should always strive to remain transparent and communicate clearly with residents.

Clark Simson Miller offers smart financial management services to homeowners associations and condominiums, including help with budget preparation and special assessments. Call us today at 865.315.7505 or email us at help@csmhoa.com to learn more!

 

RELATED ARTICLES: